Brave New World vs. 1984: Comparing Two Dystopian Masterpieces

05.11.2023 // By Tome Tailor

George Orwell’s 1984 (View on Amazon) and Aldous Huxley’s Brave New World (View on Amazon) are often pitted against each other as two of the most popular and influential dystopian novels of the 20th century. While both works offer chilling visions of future societies gone wrong, they differ significantly in the ways in which they explore themes of freedom, individualism, and state control. In this article, we will compare the two masterpieces to better understand their messages and enduring influence on modern literature and culture.

Setting and World-Building

1984 is set in Airstrip One, a province of the totalitarian superstate Oceania governed by the oppressive Party, led by the enigmatic Big Brother. Orwell presents a grim, bleak, and colorless world where the Party has complete control over all aspects of society, from thoughts and emotions to language and history.

Brave New World takes place in a distant future, where the World State has established itself as the global government. This world is characterized by a seemingly utopian environment of technological advancements, genetic engineering, and hedonism. Citizens are divided into castes and bred for specific roles in society, with no room for individuality or emotional connections.

Themes of Oppression and Control

Both novels explore the dangers of totalitarian regimes and the ways they can strip people of their freedoms and individuality. In 1984, Big Brother employs surveillance, manipulation of language, and psychological torture to suppress dissent and create a monolithic society.

In Brave New World, on the other hand, the World State enforces conformity through seemingly benevolent means: conditioning, genetic engineering, and widespread use of soma, a drug that keeps people happy and docile. Huxley explores the idea that a society centered around the pursuit of pleasure and avoidance of pain may lead to oppression that’s even more insidious, because it leaves little room for resistance.

The Protagonists: Winston Smith vs. John the Savage

Winston Smith is the protagonist of 1984. He’s an average citizen of Oceania, who secretly rebels against the oppressive regime by starting a diary and seeking human connection in a forbidden relationship. Winston’s journey serves as a chilling exploration of the lengths to which a totalitarian state can go to crush individualism and dissent.

In Brave New World, John the Savage is an outsider who has been raised on a remote Native American reservation. He represents everything the World State opposes; he values literature, religion, and emotional connection. His experiences in the new world serve as a critique of a society that upholds shallow pleasure and conformity over deeper human values.

Messages and Enduring Influence

Both 1984 and Brave New World are terrifying cautionary tales that warn against the dangers of totalitarianism and the loss of individualism. However, they approach their subject matter differently. Orwell paints a grim picture where the state imposes suffering to maintain control, whereas Huxley envisions a world where humans have been conditioned to love their servitude.

These dystopian masterpieces continue to be relevant today, as they raise important questions about privacy, freedom, and the role technology plays in our lives. 1984 has become synonymous with government surveillance and state control, while Brave New World warns about the threat of technology, consumerism, and the loss of individualism.

In conclusion, 1984 and Brave New World are two iconic dystopian novels that offer distinct visions of a nightmarish future. While both share themes of oppression and the loss of individualism, they approach these ideas in unique ways, providing readers with thought-provoking, chilling worlds to explore. If you haven’t experienced these masterpieces yet, now is the time to dive in:

By immersing yourself in these dystopian worlds, you will gain a deeper understanding of the themes and warnings that continue to resonate in today’s society.

Recommended Articles:

Looking for Something Else?